top of page

File a Claim

You should contact an agent to make a claim as soon as possible after the incident* occurs. We recommend that you contact the insurance carrier (e.g., Progressive, Travelers, etc.) of your policy, since they will handle your claim directly. You can find the contact information for all of our carriers below.

 

However, you are welcome to make a claim through us at GPA Insurance, but note that this may take longer to process your claim, since this requires relaying the information over to your carrier. Additionally, feel free to contact us before officially making a claim if you would like our consultation and advice if you have any questions or concerns regarding your insurance.

 

*Please note that claims can only be made for accidental damage/loss.

ALLEGANY.png

Allegany

Online Payment »

Phone: ​1-800-333-1679

​Billing Address: Allegany Co-op Insurance Company 75 Remittance Drive Suite 6213 Chicago, IL 60675-6213

FLOODSMART.png

FloodSmart.gov

Payment Guide »â€‹

Billing Phone:1-800-427-4661

FOREMOST.png

Foremost

Online Payment »â€‹

Billing Phone: 1-800-532-4221

HAGERTY.png

Hagerty

Online Payment »â€‹

Billing Phone: 877-922-9701​

Billing Address: Hagerty Insurance AgencyPO Box 1303Traverse City, MI 49685-1303

KEMPER.png

Kemper

Online Payment »â€‹

Billing Phone: 800-933-8788​

Billing Address: Kemper Specialty CaliforniaP.O. Box 660420 Dallas, TX 75266-0420

NATIONALGENERAL.png

National General

Online Payment »â€‹

Billing Phone:1-800-462-2123

NYCM.png

NYCM

Online Payment »â€‹

Billing Phone: 800-234-6926

​Billing Address: New York Central Mutual 1899 Central Plaza East

Edmeston, NY 13335-1899​

 

A.Central Insurance Company

1899 Central Plaza East Suite 2000

Edmeston, NY 13335-1898

SHELTERPOINT.png

Shelter Point

Online Payment »â€‹

Phone: 1-800-365-4999​

PROGRESSIVE.png

Progressive

Online Payment »â€‹

​

Mobile App Payment »â€‹

Billing Phone:1-800-876-5581

or 1-800-PROGRESSIVE

available 24/7​

Billing Address: use payment stub, but if sending without a stub mail to: Progressive Insurance

DEPT 0561

Carol Stream, IL 60132-0561

Screenshot 2026-04-30 at 11.27.50 AM.png

Security Mutual Life

Online Payment »â€‹

Phone: 1-800-765-6668​

Billing Address:100 Court Street

PO Box 1625

Binghamton, NY 13902-1625

Travelers-logo.png

Travelers

PERSONAL INSURANCE​

Online Payment »â€‹

Billing Phone:1-800-842-5075

available Monday-Friday, 8:45am-11pm

Saturday 8:45-5:00pm​

Billing Address:Travelers Personal Insurance

PO Box 660307

Dallas, TX 75266-0307​

 

COMMERCIAL INSURANCE

​Online Payment »â€‹

Billing Phone:1-800-252-2268

available Monday-Friday, 7am-8pm​

Billing Address:Travelers Commercial Lines

PO Box 660317

Dallas, TX 75266-0317

bottom of page